Since I was diagnosed, I’ve found it hard to define my emotions until this evening. In a discussion with Antoinette and Tallulah, something Tallulah said helped me define it. I had an identity for forty-six years; now that person is gone, replaced by a fraction (in using this term I don’t mean a quarter, I mean one hundredth) of the man I used to be. Now I struggle to hold onto the memories of the past. Why? Because a fractious persona creates the stronger more current memories. The defining voice that once narrated the memories, my voice – now replaced by my augmented voice “Microsoft David American.” Really! Who the f*** is David?
This led me to wonder a lot about grief and the experience of loss. I came across the following, “People don’t talk about grief, especially outside the context of a recent loss (death). It’s a private experience often hidden in our society, an experience that we are incredibly uncomfortable facing, yet one that every person on earth will eventually have.”
It made me wonder why we don’t get taught to deal with grief in its different forms. Why are we taught to deal with all other emotions!? Grief, a taboo! Why? Because most people consider grief related to death, and death for some reason, is an uncomfortable topic. What about grief unrelated to death? What about grief in terms of loss? Although, death will inevitably follow at some point. Society forgets to acknowledge this loss and the grief associated with it, often no different from death. Miscarriage, Alzheimer’s, dementia, ALS, or loss through trauma? These things impact not only the person affected by the disease, but the immediate family too. This loss we are not taught to deal with. I mean, how could we be. None of us want to predict this grievous loss or role play it, but if we addressed it through death and accepted death as we do life, might we be better prepared for it?
Who am I? I don’t know! I’m not who I used to be. I’ve experienced loss, significant loss. The past thirty months I’ve lost it all. Not the loves of my life, not my financial position, worse. I’ve lost what it meant to be me! Who am I? What’s left of me? Is there anything meaningful left? No! At this moment, nothing at all. What did I lose? My passions that defined me. The process of real estate development, running, exercising, scuba diving, eating, intelligent spontaneous conversation, wit, sarcasm, irony, food, my car, the ability to be intimate and most of all what defined me – my voice. What am I? Quadriplegic, no passions, no voice, no ability to eat or drink, reliant on others to do everything. Another person! I don’t like what I see or what I have become. This fractious persona crept up on me, knowingly. What did I do, move forward? I thought accepting the disease would make it easy. I didn’t realise the loss doesn’t go away; it doesn’t make the pain any less painful! It doesn’t make memories narrated by David any easier to accept. I’ve experienced loss without death. Death will come at some point, but how cruel. Take everything that defines you, remove it, leave you a shadow of who you were and then you finally die. How miserable! So, it turns out I’m an angry fractious quadriplegic waiting for death! Who can I direct the anger at? Myself, my brain, my DNA, as it turns out, no one!
What I’ve realised, it’s not just me experiencing the loss. My carers, my beautiful girls, Antoinette and Tallulah, experience loss and grief with every stage of the disease. The loss of warm loving touch, the loss of an intimate spontaneous conversation, the loss of an adventure engaging Pops. The loss continues every day, no relief, it continues relentlessly. How do they grieve this loss when the fractious shadow still exists? Society doesn’t realise that this grief is as intense as grief for a death, it hurts daily, minute by minute. It doesn’t let up, but life continues. Then finally, death! The grief everyone understands. But how are the family meant to deal with grief for the loss of “their person” until then? The loss is like a dark thunderous sky, it covers everything! CS Lewis defined what loss feels like in a simple way, “It doesn’t really matter whether you grip the arms of the dentist’s chair or let your hands lie in your lap. The drill drills on.” Only it comes in waves, you experience a joyous moment, relief from the drill, momentarily it feels normal. Then the high-pitched whining begins again. Does it ever stop?
For in grief nothing ‘stays put.’ One keeps on emerging from a phase, but it always recurs. Round and round. Everything repeats. Am I going in circles, or dare I hope I am on a spiral?” My loss I know is a spiral, ending in death. I know the loss for my beautiful girls will continue round and round! Like waves against a shoreline, some days fierce, intensely battering the shore! Some days calm and peaceful and other days with a ferocious rip tide that feels like it’s sucking you in and it’s just about to drown you, then spontaneously it ends, and calm beautiful blue water caresses the shoreline again. The memories happy, the day joyous. At some point I pray that the ferocious waves disappear, becoming a peaceful azure lagoon filled with memories, caressing the shoreline.
Until then we experience the loss and the grief day by day. Oh yes, there is more to lose, what ever facial expression I have left, the smile, the raising of my eyebrows. Soon it will all be gone! Unable to show my anger towards this disease, unable to punch a wall, kick the door or let out the spine-chilling scream of pain! I suppose I could cry and let the tears of sadness and anger roll down my face, until someone wipes them dry. I could just move forward; move forward with the hand I’ve been dealt. One thing is certain, I know that the thing I want is exactly the thing I can never get back. The old life, the jokes, the laughter, the arguments, the Intimacy, the work, the burgers and beers, even the heart-breaking common place moments. I’ll follow the spiral, downwards. Perhaps the best is knowing the least where the spiral ends. Trying to make the most of the new memories, even if narrated by Microsoft David, fractious quadriplegic!
However, it’s not me I’m concerned about. My beautiful girls, going round and round. Where do we take them, how do we cope with their continuing loss? “And grief still feels like fear. Perhaps, more strictly, like suspense. Or like waiting; just hanging about waiting for something to happen. It gives life a permanently provisional feeling.”
#ChallengeALSDXB
Judi
Oh Peter another beautifully written piece and one that didn’t make me cry but made me think about how right you are about grief and what you and your beautiful girls are going through but most of all you, l cannot begin to understand what it must be like for you living with this awful disease and the grief you go through every time you lose another part of yourself. Your strength and determination in fighting ALS is such an inspiration. In ending i just want you to know that l will be here for your girls today, tomorrow, always. Love you posh Peter xx
Jackie Gallagher
Dearest Peter, you help us through your writing to get a glimpse of what you are going through. Grief of the loss of everything you have lost for both you and your girls, your mom and dad – cannot begin to know what you are all experiencing but you help us to recognize that we need to treasure so much the ordinary. Thank you for your honesty. Love from Jackie
Andre
‘David’ may have pulled in uninvited, but we know exactly who you were, are and always will be my boet! Your girls are superhero’s, tough to to the bone! And beautiful for loving you the way they do!! Love you always!!
Sancho
There are some things in this world that we are never meant to understand such as faith, such as death. It’s something that is inherent with life. Humanity can try to give meaning to these things, analyze it, publish about it, and eventually try to prevent it but in the end it will happen. The only difference from each individual is time. Your feelings of anger and frustration to a different point of view is a good sign. There is still a spark in your mind that wills itself to go on living. Let it out and screw MND. If you’re tired of hearing David be your voice you can always go for Microsoft Anna to tell your stories just for laughs.
Pieter
Khalil Gibran wrote in one of his books “The Prophet”
“Your children are not your children..you may house their bodies but not their souls.
This had such a profound effect upon me and it made me realise that my love and admiration for you will always keep our souls connected no matter what!!
When you hurt..We all hurt…your concerns are also our concerns…Your questions are also our questions which we use for our never ending debates with the universe..We are so not prepared for what life throws at us in any given moment…Are we scared..yes i am..Our sadness knows no end as we try to come to grips with our daily experiences..
I can only agree with you as you so eloquently put it in this beautifully written deeply touching Meme ..
Your words:
“It gives life a permanently provisional feeling.”.
No matter how hard we try to understand…Herein lies my consolation…
I loved and appreciated and learned so much from you since the day you were born…
May our souls be connected forever..
Love you!!!!
Oumi
Pieter, this is your most poignant blog thus far 😢 but every word is the truth.
Antoinette & Tallulah are two amazing women. During the last 30 months grieving every single loss with you they have cared for you like no other could have, I salute A & T. ❤️
You are so right when you say we are not prepared to talk about grief or death.You Pieter are the person that brought about me talking death for the first time in my life. To your Nan when she was dying. You asked me, does Nan know she is dying ? she has a right to know. I hadn’t prepared myself to talk about death, even though I knew I was facing the inevitable.
The opportunity arose, we were alone and I thought of your words. Mom do you know you are dying, I felt like my heart would burst open, my mother answered, I knew something would get me sooner or later. With that we both laughed and a short conversation thereafter.
My mother’s death left me thinking a lot about death but it was always about my own death, never any other person. So am I ready to face my own death, I don’t know yet. But one thing for certain is, I am not ready to face the death of my son. Nothing can prepare me for this. It’s been thirty months of grieving for my son and as you rightly say, just hanging about waiting for something to happen.
You ask the question, who am I. The answer to that is you are my son, in every sense of the word. ALS will never take that away from me.
I love you to the moon and beyond , as my friend Beverley always says, you rock my world.
PAT I love you with all my heart ❤️
Beverley
Dearest Peter,
Wow wow your words your feelings your love is so powerful 🤗 I salute you. Bless you the big warrior. Xx keep writing.
Seth
Powerful and honest, Peter. But you still have you mind and your language skills, American David’s voice notwithstanding. Keep writing.
Debbie
As always Peter, such profound insight into a very emotional and sad subject, one which touches and effects every one of us so differently, and for so many different reasons. As difficult as it is for all of you, and I can only imagine how difficult, We feel like we have been privileged to learn from all of you every single day! We have watched each of one of you beautiful people, grieve at a different time in the last 30 months as you grieve at your own pace, but a few things all three of you have in common and we can all learn from, is your tenacity, your ability to see each new day as a blessing and an opportunity to make new memories, your determination to overcome every new challenge this dreadful illness brings to your family, your smart enquiring minds, your ability to smile at the end of a tough day and week, and your empathy for those around you even though you are all going through a tough time yourselves. Thank you for giving of yourselves so willingly to those of us lucky enough to be part of your journey. We love you all very much.
Lee Ann
Peter, you write so expressively & honestly: thank you for the gift of sharing 💚🙏💚
In Māori, we are usually introduced to grief from childhood & death, loss & sadness are all a part of the cycle of life. This doesn’t make the process pain-free, it does help.
As I (currently) face my own mortality & the limitations of serious illness, I relate to your sharing on so many levels. Along with the losses, I’ve gotten better at letting things go – in between releasing anger, frustration & tears – including in front of my loved ones. There’s healing & connection in those tears for all of us. In a recent visit from my siblings (4/5 live in Oz), everyone was trying to keep it together & I could sense it; as soon as I let my tears flow, it was like it gave my family ‘permission’ to do so.
No matter what ALS attempts to take away from you, you will always be the very loved Dad, husband, son, bro, friend, Property Developer, marathon-er, etc. You may lose your memories &, you will be remembered for WHO you are & the difference you bring to the world: look into Tallulah’s eyes & remind yourself.
Huge peace ✌ & 💖 LAx
Margaret Cross
So perfectly expressed. I feel the same for my husband and daughters, and yet there seems so little to ehlp them cope through this ‘waiting’ period.
Rachel Humphrey
Thank you, so eloquently put into words what we go through every day until the end.
Bless you.
Hazel
My husband, Alan, died from MND 5th June. Reading your piece made me cry because you are spot on. I don’t know how you cope or how he coped. I tried so hard to make life cheerful for my Alan, and I did all I could but I never felt it was enough. I knew that he must have been going trough some sort of internal torture – and you have put that torture into words. It hurts to know he was and you are going through his. I don’t do anger, just sadness. So very sorry you and your family, and so many other families, are having to go through this. We need a cure !!!!!!!!
Susan Matthews
Hello Peter, such beautiful words but written with some anger which I don’t blame you for having. I am going to write something that a lot of people might taken offense to so I want to apologise now for any upset caused.
Where is this “Merciful” God that is spoken about in the Bible so many times? Why did this “Merciful” God inflict this disgusting disease on someone we love so much? Where is this “Merciful” God when one of his flock just has to wait around for Him to decided the inevitable? I realise that we were put on this earth for a short while but where is He when you need Him the most. Has the world got so bad that He hasn’t got time for everybody? In times like this it makes me wonder……..
I am APOLIGISING again if I have offended anyone with my thoughts to Peter and his two wonderful girls, but these are just another rant about this horrible disease.
Peter, Antoinette and Tallulah you are always in my thoughts and I will still say a prayer for all of you, just in case God is in my neighbourhood at the time.
I love you all to infinity xxxxx
Abir
I love you so much Peter ,thinking of you and what you and my sweethearts Antoinette and T go through make me feel strong ,I can can only say you are the bravest man I even met or will meet.
Good bless you .
I love you ❤️😘
Thierry Gaillot
Dear Peter
It is very emotional to read you. Yours words are so moving and so meaningful. Indeed, when in good health, every one should realize how good is life. I often think about you and what you are going through. And despite that, you are still finding the strenght to write. I can only admire you. I am sure your words can help other suffering people but also everyone to live fully their life before it is too late. I wish you a lot of courage as well as your family. Lots of love. Thierry